USB-C vs. Thunderbolt 3: Which One is Better?

USB-C vs. Thunderbolt 3: Which One is Better?

The ubiquity of the USB-C connection has brought many benefits, but it has also caused some confusion. This is particularly true when it comes to Thunderbolt 3. Many modern laptops boast USB-C ports, but only some of these support Thunderbolt 3 (TB3). Laptops that boast TB3 often come at a price premium over those with only USB-C. So which one is the best option for you?

We at Cable Matters hope to burn away the fog surrounding USB-C vs. Thunderbolt 3 so you can make an informed decision as to whether USB-C will be enough or if you need the additional features of a TB3 connection.

What exactly is USB-C?

USB-C (formally known as USB Type-C) and Thunderbolt 3 describe different things. USB-C is, by itself, just a form-factor for a connection. Think of USB-C as an evolution of the design of older boxy USB connectors (known as Type-A). USB-C is a reversible connector, which means no more fiddling when plugging it in. It also has more pins than USB-A, allowing for increased power delivery, data transfer speeds, and video bandwidth to travel across the cable.  

In general, when the term “USB-C” is used in the product description, it should be seen as shorthand for “a USB port that uses the Type-C form factor.” Many tech outlets and retailers have muddied the waters by using the term “USB-C” to refer to both the transfer specifications and the form factor. For comparison's sake, the term "USB-C" will refer to both the USB Type-C form factor and USB 3.2 data specification concurrently throughout the rest of the article. More information about USB-C and the USB 3.2 specification can be found here. Thunderbolt 3, by contrast, refers to specifications detailing transfer speeds, data bandwidth, and more. The take-home message is to remember that TB3 uses a USB-C connector but offers additional features over the vanilla USB protocol.

The USB Type-C connection (left) features a different design than the older USB Type-A connection type (right).

 USB-C vs. Thunderbolt 3: Which One is Better?USB-C vs. Thunderbolt 3: Which One is Better?

Similarities between USB-C and Thunderbolt 3

When discussing USB-C vs. Thunderbolt 3, it’s important to note that both connections share quite a bit in common. Both use the Type-C form factor for the connection. Both USB-C and TB3 can be used to power devices, transfer data at high speeds, and connect a variety of peripherals including displays. Both can be used to connect a computer to a compatible docking station, which you may want to use.

Differences between USB-C and Thunderbolt 3

While USB-C and TB3 offer similar general functionality, there are noticeable differences between the two standards. The key differences between USB-C and TB3 can be boiled down to three main points: data transfer rates, display connections, and connecting external devices.

  1. Data transfer: Thunderbolt 3 is significantly faster than USB-C. USB-C supports transfer speeds ranging from 480 Mbps (USB 2.0) to 20 Gbps (USB 3.2 Gen 2x2); 10 Gbps is the most common speed. Thunderbolt 3 supports transfer rates up to 40 Gbps. In general, a laptop with Thunderbolt 3 can transfer data over that port to another device 2-4 times faster than a laptop with USB-C. The attached device must support those speeds (e.g., a Thunderbolt 3 external hard drive).
  2. Display connections: One of the big draws of Thunderbolt 3 is its versatility. In addition to offering blazingly fast transfer speeds, Thunderbolt 3 has the bandwidth to drive up to two 4K monitors at 60 Hz. USB-C can also support external displays with the optional “DisplayPort Alternate Mode” feature. Without this feature, displays will not work when connected via USB-C. Verify that your computer supports this feature if you intend to use an external display over USB-C.
  3. Device support: USB-C and TB3 can both be used to connect a variety of peripherals such as printers and hard drives. TB3, however, supports PCIe devices like external GPUs and fast external hard drives. USB-C simply cannot connect to these kinds of devices.
  4. Daisy-chaining: TB3 supports daisy-chaining. Up to 6 compatible devices can be connected in a chain using their own TB3 ports instead of connecting to the host device. With USB-C, these devices would all need to connect to individual host USB-C ports.
  5. Backward compatibility: TB3 is compatible with USB-C. If a USB-C device is plugged into a TB3 port, the port reverts to USB-C mode to support the device. Compatibility is not reciprocal, however. A USB-C only port will not work with a Thunderbolt 3 device. Thunderbolt 3 docking stations such as the one below require a Thunderbolt 3 host.

USB-C vs. Thunderbolt 3: Which One is Better?

If you need fast transfer speeds, support for multiple 4K 60Hz displays, or an external GPU, look for the Thunderbolt 3 lightning bolt symbol. (Buy the Aluminum Thunderbolt 3 dock here.)

Do you need Thunderbolt 3, or is USB-C enough?

The decision between USB-C and Thunderbolt 3 comes down to your personal usage. You should consider these three points before making a purchase:

  1. Are my file transfers time-sensitive? Most laptops with USB-C can transfer a full-length HD movie in 30 seconds or fewer. If you’re not regularly transferring large data sets on a deadline from an external device that benefits from the increased speeds, you likely won’t benefit from TB3’s 40Gbps transfer speeds
  2. Do I need to use two 4K 60Hz monitors? If the answer is no, then USB-C (or an HDMI or DisplayPort) connection should be perfectly fine for connecting a monitor.  USB-C will power two 4K 30Hz monitors, but you’ll need Thunderbolt 3 to bump that up to 60Hz.
  3. Do I want an external GPU for gaming or rendering work? You will need a computer with Thunderbolt 3 to be able to connect an eGPU (at least until USB4 comes out). If you don’t need or want an external GPU, USB-C is perfectly fine.

USB-C vs. Thunderbolt 3: Final Points

In general, USB-C will meet the needs of most people. However, there are specific use cases where Thunderbolt 3 is advantageous (or even necessary). Faster data transfer speeds (40 Gbps vs. 10-20 Gbps), support for two high-resolution displays, and the ability to connect devices like external GPUs are only available via Thunderbolt 3.

Keep in mind that Thunderbolt 3 is a proprietary connection, the copyright of which is owned by Intel. As such, Thunderbolt 3 often comes at a price over USB-C. If work doesn’t demand data-hungry peripherals, USB-C is a flexible and cost-effective option for most users.

Comments (5) -

  • Which connection do you recommend for connecting new MacBook Pro to an old printer with a USB CABLE 3.0, 3.1, 3.2, or something else.
    Thanks
    Brad Summers
    • Hi Brad, great question!  If we assume USB-C on the Macbook end then we can connect to whichever data port the printer has available, whether it is USB-A, USB-B, 2.0 or 3.0. Most printers use USB-B 2.0 as a connector, however: https://www.cablematters.com/pp/201002/

      If you're wondering what speed is necessary, then the transfer speed of USB 2.0 is plenty for what a printer needs. There is no benefit from using a faster cable.
  • What cable should be used to connect a Thunderbolt 4 laptop with a USB C Docking Station that's compatible with Thunderbolt 3? The dock works when I connect the USB C to the USB A port for everything BUT power delivery, but the USB C to C Cable does not work in connecting the USB C Docking Station to the Thunderbolt 4 port on the laptop.

    Please advise.

    Sincerely,
    Sai
    • Hello Sai,

      A full-feature USB-C to C cable will be sufficient to connect your Thunderbolt 4 computer to a USB-C docking station. However, many USB-C cables are not full feature, meaning they don't support power, video, or 10Gbps data.  Please email us at support@cablematters.com with your specific equipment and we'll be happy to help further.
  • How do I know if my computer can handle a ThunderBolt PCI-e or PCI add-in card.
    The born on date of my home computer is pre-2012 and currently running Windows 10 very nicely.

    I use it for Streaming, transferring files within my 3 computer home LAN, Web browsing, email, texting.... not much strain going on here.  

    I'd be curios to know if my PC can handle it.

Add comment

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Learn More

OK